Sentencing Guidelines - Offences

12 judgments

11 November 2005

Bernard Philip Mary Rooney, Denis Michael Dorrian, Gerard Martin Paul Irvine, Seamus Patrick Cunningham and Sean Martin Joseph Doran. Attorney General's Reference (No. 1 of 2005) (AG Ref 6-10 of 2005)

This is the guideline judgment which authoritatively lays down correct procedure to be followed in this jurisdiction when a sentencing indication is sought by a defendant.

[2005] NICA 44
Kerr LCJ
27 October 2005

R v Charles Malachy Oliver Pollock

Death of constable struck by car attempting to avoid police stinger device after a chase. Aggravation and mitigation - effect of lack of intention. 12 year sentence not unreasonable - Also statement that there should be less discount for a plea of guilty caught red handed.

[2005] NICA 43
Kerr LCJ
16 September 2005

R v Joseph Henry Bateson

Historic sexual offences - rape and indecent assault - historic cases - effect of delay on sentence - youth of offender.

[2005] NICA 37
Nicholson LJ
06 July 2005

R v Martin Kerr Attorney General's Reference (No 4 of 2005)

Indecent assaults - guidance on sexual offences against young children - abuse of trust - significant adverse effect on victim - offences committed over period in respect of which offender had been previously dealt with in relation to similar offences against others.

[2005] NICA 33
Kerr LCJ
04 July 2005

R v Sean Kenneth Murphy

GBH and robbery (2 separate offences) - consecutive sentences - custody probation order.

[2005] NICA 32
Campbell LJ
17 June 2005

R v Joanne Elizabeth Mitchell

s. 20 OAPA - neglect of a child/baby - suitability for probation.

[2005] NICA 30
Kerr LCJ
15 April 2005

David Cyril Dawson, Jerome Campbell and Darren Martin, Attorney General's Reference (No 8 of 2004) (AG Ref 11,12 & 13 of 2004)

Reference by AG - whether sentences unduly lenient - drugs offences - Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 - importation of drugs into Northern Ireland - substantial quantity of drugs - intention of Judge to pass non-custodial sentence - failure of the prosecution to inform the judge of relevant authorities - application refused.

[2005] NICA 18
Kerr LCJ
11 February 2005

R v George Angus McKenzie

Possessing a weapon designed to discharge a noxious liquid gas or thing, contrary to Section 6(1)(b) of Firearms (NI) Order 1981 (as amended) - questions to ask when considering appropriate disposal of firearms offences - suspended sentence - R v. Avis and Others [1998] 1 Cr App R applied.

[2005] NICA 7
Nicholson LJ
10 February 2005

R v Gerard Patrick Stewart [2004] NICC 23

Murder and attempted murder - 18 year old female victim - stabbing - fled scene - previous record for violence - higher starting point - killed to let prisoner escape - failure to respond to previous sentences - youth (20) - personality difficulties - tariff fixed at 17 years.

[2005] NILST 4
Kerr LCJ
31 January 2005

R v Kenneth Henry Callaghan

Rape and murder - 22 year old female victim - broke into home - multiple blows to head by blunt metal instrument - initially denied offence - confessed when confronted by evidence - claimed the attack was the result of a psychotic episode - no supporting evidence - higher starting point - age - belated plea of guilty - tariff fixed at 21 years.

[2005] NILST 2
Kerr LCJ
31 January 2005

R v Ian Alexander Quinn

Murder - 76 year old female victim - burglary at night - armed with a knife - sustained, vicious attack - sexual assault - socially withdrawn psychopath - higher starting point - age (18) - guilty plea - tariff fixed at 22 years.

[2005] NILST 3
Kerr LCJ
04 January 2005

R v Samuel David Joseph Cummins

One of several men who attacked male victim after night out at nightclub - higher starting point - concerted, savage, merciless attack - substantial sentence for the retribution and deterrence aspects - no tangible evidence of genuine remorse - conceivable did not intend to kill - tariff fixed at 15 years.

[2005] NILST 1
Kerr LCJ